I probably don't have the correct terms like the pros here, but I believe you have the 3rd issue. The inserts for the CJ would be concave and follow the circle. The hat and cane would be shiny if it was CJ. There's a pic of yours on page254 of C&Ws book. Look at
http://www.thechiprack.com/visual/nnev/nvcncc.htm for the difference in the $25 denom