You stated "In my opinion, some things are best left to those who know what they are doing and have a responsibility."

What does that mean? I was only asking for opinions as I didnt want to give the wrong info to the member in question. I personally would love to see both these members get theirs but this is not my fight.

So, who is the best person with this responsibility you indicate? Inquiring minds want to know?

So far based on the response here and the many emails I have already received the concensus is to expose the members. I agree it is a slippery slope which is why I posted the question.

He will most likely after our conversation do all 3. First file a claim with eBay, then when he finishes with eBay file a claim with the club and if all else fails post here on the board.