As a matter of fact Rick, I was privy to them and I didnt see where he was rude to you as you claimed.
He made you an offer regarding replacing them which IMO was very fair.
Anyway, that is a matter for you and him to sort out.

You claim that Josh jumped into this thread for support. That was not the reason I chose to post though. I though it was unfair for you to try and use unrealistic feedback statistics to gain your own support.
You just stated "You are also overlooking the fact that one of those negs was recent and WAS ALSO FROM A FELLOW CLUB MEMBER!"

Where exactly is that negative? It certainly doesnt show up in his feedback when I look through it. Can you show me please?
The last negative was over 6 months ago from a buyer with (-1) feedback.
The previous one to that was 2 years ago.
Both those related to slow delivery only.
The one before that was 4 years ago.

If you are going to try and make a case for yourself, then at least use facts. If you can see a recent neg from a fellow club member I think you are looking at the wrong persons feedback.