$1 for 2 Utah "P" quarters is for sure fair!!
The "P" quarters are a bit more saught after. 50 cents per quarter is a fair price. On another note Utah won the award for the best design out of all 50 states. Just another reason to get them. Chips are great to collect but can depreciate in value. Coins either go up in value or stay the same. You don't loose anything. Just a thought.