Yes AdamL, I would think that $19.00 is a tad bit too high of value for that token. A Proof example of that that same token should sell for $8 - $10 from most dealers. The condition of your token would sell for $3 - $6 in most cases.

Tokens rarely sell for more than their clay counterparts unless the token was a special production piece or minted on a different blank (for example the 1965 Harvey’s token minted in Platinum).

I hope whoever gets the token appreciates it as much as other collectors do.