Wow, at least he was up front in actually putting my question and his fully honest (but silly) reply right into his auction page, not that he expects to get much from the chip. Interesting the way eBay now lets the seller put questions and answers right into the auction. (I guess it is not automatic that it gets in?) For those interested, here is the link to the auction:
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&rd=1&item=6137774214

And to see my question and the answer, you scroll down to "Questions from other buyers."

How do you answer something so ridiculous. With his logic, you could paste a reproduction or a fantasy anything over an old common Paulson California Bell chip and call it a good old valuable Paulson so-and-so casino chip because it is on a Paulson mold chip or blank. David, since he pasted it over an old casino chip, to stop the making of Borland fakes of fakes, you would have to buy up every Nevada-Nevada chip in the world!

Robert