No Archie, its not tongue in cheek.

I think five judges is plenty, but not necessarily the same five for each catagory.

I think nominations should come from the entire membership so that the Judges don't have know every chip, token, silver strike, slot card which was issued the previous year.

I understand that that many members believe the entire membership should vote on every thing, but I have never supported that thinking.

What is even worse is the idea that the whole membership should vote on the Hall of Fame. I think this is redicoulous. Many of us don't know the people involved or only know some of them. We have no basis to be Judges. I think HOF voting should be done by HOF members and maybe the BOD.