Greetings,
I have just one question to ask of those who advocate some standard system of chip grading: Why?
I have yet to see a valid reason. Obviously this is a sensitive issue that could cause a lot of ill will among chippers. So why pursue it? Why is it so important?
I haven't had any problem with either collectors I've traded with or dealers I've bought from, including some on both sides of this discussion. I am able to understand descriptions such as "worn" "weak hot stamp" or "a few knicks" or "a cigarette burn" or what have you, and can decide whether to buy a chip sight unseen from those descriptions. If it is a face-to-face deal, then I can see for myself whether the chip is something I want and can decide if the price is fair--to me.
The idea that condition is a major factor in price is just that, an idea.
It only becomes fact if the general population involved in a hobby is willing to accept it.
And that, in my humble opinion, would be the only reason for advocating a grading system. To force chippers to accept the idea that "grade equals price" and pay more for a chip that is slightly, perhaps subjectively, in "better" condition than another.
So, the only reason I see for a standardized grading system is MONEY. What other reason is there?
If you are in this for the money, then I see why you would want such a grading sytem. If you are, as I am, in this for the hobby, history and just plain fun, then where is the benefit? I can't honestly see how a sytem that would inevitably make this hobby a helluvalot more MERCENARY would benefit the chipping community as a whole.
Since I have become active in chip collecting, I've enjoyed the informal system; someone offers a trade or sale and I decide if the chip is worth what they are asking. Me--not some price guide or self-elected arbiter. I'm very comfortable deciding for myself what a chip is worth--to me. I assume everyone else can do the same for themselves.
So I ask again: Why? If there is some other reason than MONEY, I'm willing to listen. But if that's all you can come up with, I'll stay firmly in the camp that opposes such a grading system.
Cheers,
Russ McDermott