I certainly would. Once i have received the check from the insurace company that transaction is over and done with. The second chair would then give me two. The insurance company on the lost chair could either replace the chair with an equal chair or give me the replacement value of it. Once thats done...its done and i would be able to buy as many as i would be lucky enough to find. However....should i find that chair before the deal is done....the insurance company would expect me to purchase that chair on their behalf. They of course would be more then willing to cover my $2.00