Thanks everyone for all of the advice and support so far. I would have understood if the seller had listed these chips in error for this price but when he straight out told me that they were mine, I assumed they were mine. The chips in question were the following: $1 Aladdin gray with the pic of the lamp, $1 Hotel Fremont blue with the pic of the guy, and the $1 Circus Circus off white with the pic of the ringmaster from like 1968. What are the chances of having some way to mark who is and isn't a member everytime they post? It seems like a good idea to me. I didn't mean to open up a can of worms with this topic just kind of letting people know and venting a little. Hopefully I can add these chips to my collection someday. Thanks guys, Dan