Maybe I'm wrong. In my opinion the top ashtray is kind of square with bevelled edges. I think you can see the background around the whole ashtray so that's its shape. In my opinion the bottom ashtray is a round ashtray with the photo clipped around the edges. Otherwise it would seem to be a shape I'm not familiar with. Oddly I did own the bottom ashtray. I donated maybe 100 Vegas ashtrays to the Club and Charles Kaplan was kind enough to scan each ashtray, enter it into the ChipGuide and credit me.