The Chip Board
Custom Search
   


The Chip Board Archive 25

Procedure is posted on Club chatboard
In Response To: Present procedures... ()

The Hall of Fame procedure has been posted on the Club chatboard.

While the procedure does not list "groups", it does list "person" and "member" as singular.

Any possible group of club members could always be recommended as individuals.

One problem with recommending a group is that it is an all or nothing option.
While some of the group may be well qualified there could also be part of the group that
may not be recommendation material. Using a group would be unfair to all its members.
I AM NOT SAYING THIS IS THE CASE IN THIS DISCUSSION THREAD.
Just pointing out a downfall of recommending a group.

Another problem that could exist is in the final voting procedure for Hall of Fame
members. Each member is allowed three votes on the final ballot. Does a group of
three receive one only one vote because it is a group, or is the group of three using all three available votes?

The voting procedure for groups needs to be discussed. The one or three option could affect the total votes
attributed to other nominated candidates and affect their chances to be possible inductees.

Messages In This Thread

ccgtcc Please read and give your opinion
Follis, please put this on the club board also
That would have been an excellent place to post.
Re: That would have been an excellent place to pos
I just posted the link there...
Re: I just posted the link there...
Re: ccgtcc Please read and give your opinion
Re: ccgtcc Please read and give your opinion
Current HOF members
I support your proposal.
I support it
HOF nomination info
Two issues
I, too, was nominated in the past and advised ~~~
Present procedures...
Re: Present procedures...
Re: Present procedures...
Re: Present procedures...
Procedure is posted on Club chatboard
Re: Procedure is posted on Club chatboard
Re: OVER DUE HALL OF FAMER
Re: OVER DUE HALL OF FAMER
Re: OVER DUE HALL OF FAMER
I agree Rich! JAMES IS A DESERVING HALL OF FAMER
I concur 100%
Re: I concur 100%
I am on board 100% vbg

Copyright 2022 David Spragg