Good one! I have to go with Maggie May, although the first thing that came to me was song after song from my 1st semester away at college and us wearing out his 1982 Absolutely Live album. I'm torn between Sailing, Tonight's The Night, You're In My Heart [Final Acclaim}, Young Turks, and I Don't Want To Talk About It.Then you have Hot Legs and Do ya Think I'm Sexy as well. Check it out: :https://youtu.be/pNuHbNh7F_U

I hope thr concert was everything you hoped it would be! I'm happy you got to go. At least I got to see Elton John in the 2000's