Well, there it is at 612 Aultman Street. Closed down, boarded up.
I asked at the desk at the Hotel Nevada. They said Annie's never made it to the grand opening. Prior to that, they said, the location was La Fiesta, and they had machine games, but no tables. This is the same location at which Collins Court Casino closed in 1993. Looks like some history needs to be filled in for this address.