Ed's catalog is fine enough. This was hashed over at a seminar at the convention last year and I brought it up. I was told there was no way to verify many ID's and you would have people submitting phony ID's just to sell chips. Ed is kind enough not to charge us for his catalog and will be updating it even with lots more ID's. I hope he discontinues the pricing in it and uses words like scarce,common, etc. By putting prices on the chips only encourages the guy with a box to release 2 a year and make believe it is really rare. BTW most of these people only sell on eBay and are NOT members of our club. They make up stories about finding chips from a relative and I know they bid against me for groups of Illegals. What they do is usually wait a very long year or two before listing any chips then claim it was from their great uncle or grandfather. I could type their names in here but then I might get sued so I will keep it to myself and to the "splash bar"