I don't recall the EBay ID of the Feb. 09 auction. Each of the three Dec/Jan auctions was with a different seller ID. I'm certain that there's a relationship among the first three auctions as it's very unusual to auction two identical rare chips together. However, it's a fact that rumphman57 told me that he had just the two chips and then sent second chance offers to at least two other bidders. All the sellers are located in the LA area and, I think, are aware of each other. Considering the murkiness of EBay, they may all be the same person. Through PayPal I have the name and address of the person that I paid. I don't believe he's a club member or I would have certainly have filed an ethics complaint.