Let’s look at this from a totally neutral position. Say perhaps the “SlabFree” list and website were to be disbanded and taken down (and out of existence), what would be the benefits and what would be the pitfalls of doing so?

The “SlabFree” list did what it was intended to do, thwart slabbing companies from entering the hobby. I understand that since then no one is slabbing chips, so it has now become a moot point.

The only ‘possible’ benefit would be that Mark Scott would now do business with people that were on the list. But EVEN THAT is unlikely given the information Charles Kaplan provided stating Mark had made the blocked list and he would not change it since he had long since forgotten why he did it in the first place. He appears immovable in his position, I understand his original position too- there was a lot of bad blood and he was retaliating against the SlabFree members. I don’t expect him to change.

It was asked, “What does it take to be removed from the list.”
Gene replied, “A majority vote.”
What does it take to be removed from Mark Scott’s List?

Suffice to say the Mark Scott / SlabFere impasse is probably not likely to be resolved anytime soon.

Some people Agree, some disagree, some could care less…. Getting into a heated fight over it at this point in time is a complete waste of time- The battle is over. (for now).

The combatants have even run out of ammunition- they have resorted to name calling.