The Chip Board
Custom Search
   


The Chip Board Archive 19

Rich, this has already been brought up and...

to simply say, "Yeah, what he said!" is a bit contrary to overall intent here. While David's picks certainly are gems, I think the ones that you agonized over and presented already, are also quite spectacular.

As with others, I have no problem with the minor change-out of a chip or two, but to do what you are suggesting at this juncture will cause a bias to the process, at least in the beginning stages here.

While my quite lengthly post above did not make mention of this, I tend to see this Project as taking a bit of time and will perhaps see a request for a second submission in light of the chips being viewed for the first time by some. But for right now, in the spirit of diversity, I will make note of, but will reject, the wholesale duplication of someone elses efforts.

While this is the first request to change previously selected chips to David's, I have rejected another individual's contribution to just use David's picks, even though I felt that the individual was sincere in his belief that they represented his Top 10 picks as well.

My concern is that it makes too easy to participate and de-values the contributions (and work done) by others. Anyway, that's the way I see it right now, but I am always open to discussion.

Respectfully,

Jim

Messages In This Thread

Information Regarding the topten Project...
Re: Information Regarding the topten Project...
I wish! vbg Hey, did I thank you for the...
If possible, I would like to change my top 10
I'm inclined to second that, Rich!
Re: I'm inclined to second that, Rich!
I'd Love to see Mike's, TOO!!
Me three! Anyone have an email addy?
Rich, this has already been brought up and...
Re: Rich, this has already been brought up and...
Rich, I believe your sincerity and will make a...
Re: Rich, I believe your sincerity and will make a
Re: If possible, I would like to change my top 10
Re: If possible, I would like to change my top 10
grin How Appropos...
Phyllis, while it's nice to hit your...
grin Thank you, Jim!

Copyright 2022 David Spragg