I recently purchased a bunch of chips off of Craigslist from a seller that said they had some casino chips from Reno Tahoe and Las Vegas. about 2 1/2 cases, in a box. I thought cases were probably racks. So about 250 chips. They were for sale for $100.

I contacted the seller and let her know I was interested and met her. When looking at the chips, I thought I was taking a chance but there were some cool looking chips, especially a Club Cal Neva Roulette chip. I also know enough that some of the chips were still in use and all of the AC chips could be redeemed at face. I also noticed that there were no Vegas chips and only around 150 chips. I had no idea about what 95% of the chips were worth.

As it turns out there are several in there that are each "book valued" at more than I paid for the lot. What do I do now? I thought I was taking somewhat of a risk and didn't get all that was advertised, but figured I could at least get my money back by piecing the chips out if I chose to do that.

I thought I was taking a risk, albeit a safe one, but am I supposed to contact the seller back now and offer her more money now or the chips back ($100 is still a lot of money to me)?

- Tom H.