As much as I appreciate the club code of ethics and I try to follow those ethics(even before I joined the club),I could not and would not bring this up as club business and a code violation.
If he wants to make good,I will be happy. The eBay feedback thing will be good enough for me although I am still holding off on that for a couple more days at least as I hope that he will make it right.
So Josh...if you are reading this...the door is open