I disagree with you, David
Having read every post in this thread, it's very clear that Rick has made an honest attempt to get opinions from fellow club members concerning this troubling dilemma he's finding himself in. And it seems to me he has been more than fair in his attempts to resolve this problem before posting his thoughts on this message board. We, as fellow club members, either condone what has happened to him or we don't ... for me it is that simple!