He stated I never gave him a chance to say what happened. Well here is the time line:

Yesterday: I opened his bubble wrapped envelope....
[Image removed by administrator as it showed senders address. If you blank out the address it will be reposted]

Expected this chip:

Got this:

Sent this email...
I just received the chip I won in the auction. This is not the chip you listed. This chip is in horrible condition, chips on both sides as well as stains on the inlay. I feel as if i was decieved. I expect to receive the chip that was posted in the auction. If not I will report this to eBay.

Michael

His reply...
PLEASE SEND THE CHIP BACK FOR A REFUND I DO NOT AT ANY TIME TRY TO DECEIVE ANY ONE. THE CHIP WAS LISTED AS USED AND NO MORE, UPON MY RECEIVING THE CHIP I WILL REIMBURSE YOU FOR THE CHIP AND YOUR POSTAGE I DO NOT CHEAT ANY OF THE PEOPLE THAT I DEAL WITH THANKS AGAIN JACK
THIS IS THE ONLY ONE I HAVE SO THAT IS WHAT YOU RECEIVED

Didn't he just say he didn't have any others. I could of sworn he just steted he has the one listed in his possession. Crook, Liar..