...the one email wouldn't have made any difference anyway because you see/saw nothing wrong with the listing. Thank you for the clarification.

Josh wrote:
"the whole point is that i never saw anything wrong with the auction. that is why it still runs.

"jim, who is running for an office position, saw something wrong and instead of sending me an email about it tries to get me kicked out of the club and writes a stupid letter.

"jim made a complaint to the club and guess what happened. THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS DID NOT FIND ANYTHING WRONG WITH THE AUCTION EITHER. that is why it still runs."

That auction listing is misleading in my opinion Josh. Not to the point of getting you kicked out of the club, but it is still misleading. You know people feel that way, but you just don't care. Admit to that instead of making a phony claim that Jim sending you an email might have made a difference.