reading this exceptionally long thread ... is that you have 3400 of these chips??

If that is so, I don't understand why you are having a problem accepting opinions from some very knowledgeable and well respected chippers that this hoard of fantasy chips you have in substantial large quantites are definitely NOT RARE.

How would you describe casino chips that routinely sell for hundreds, or thousands, of dollars each, if you misuse the term "rare" for your chips that are available in such large numbers?

Below is a RARE chip ... only one known.