I would pay $350. The $5 with leaves has only been seen with writing around the rim. It is my theory that an old carver (or someone with time on his hands) had a goup of $5 chips and added different words on the chip. Actually I belkieve that most of the "commems" wree other chips that were recarved. However, I do believe that they are old. I'd pick 1926 (second quess is 1906).

Lastly, I'll buy every one of these type chips (Not the ones in Dale's fake section)