When someone has a problem with the condition of a chip they receive in a transaction, and they want to bring the condition of the chip in question to the attention of other collectors to make a point, they'll scan chip and show it to everyone. Did you do that? No. For someone who claims to deal in facts, a little proof to accompany your slam on another person would carry more weight than the slam alone.

As to him not wanting you to bid on anymore of his auctions, I don't blame him. I don't knowingly do business with jerks either.

Bob