Give the guy a chance to make good. Write a nice email explaining that "Excellent condition with no chips, cracks or damage" (which I cut from the auction) would indicate the chips are not warped.

I also looked and the scan doesn't show warping.

So what if the guy has a 700 pos rating and an eBay store.

Then come back here if he doesn't give a full refund. Asking for a partial is tenuous. Post his name, just in case people don't remember.

So was that auction link, that Pete posted, from Colorado Finds the right one??? Is the guy a club member? Possible CLUB complaint to whoever is doing that work now?