Campiglia's book states the value of your chip at $300, $600, $900 based on quality. Is that a bad trade for a set of chips his book values at $4,600? Even if the "hoard" drops the price by 1/3, it's still a $900 (my end) for $600 (your end, your chip is not perfect). You're still making a great deal. All of mine sold for near the opening bid. The offer still stands. You should take advantage of it.

In Response To: Sierra Tahoe Chips (Fred Roach)

... on eBay, and you offered me your 3-piece set ("$4,600 value from your end") in trade.

I was very happy to read Jim's post.