I think it depends on what the newlyweds are looking for. While JB mentioned the nice "way it was" islands the couple may prefer plain luxury. If that is the case the I don't think you can beat Atlantis on Paradise Island. I think that Atlantis has to be one of the top 5 or 10 properties in the world. Of course "money is no object" if you stay there and you should be prepared for that attitude. Whatever they decide - best wishes!