I sent the seller an e-mail to see where they came up with a book value of $1200 on the Horseshoe Arrowdie quarter chip & got the following reply back:

"Since you are on the list we feel we should help you honor your pledge.
I consider any mail from a list member a waste of
time - ours and yours.

Sahara Coins Staff"

I guess I really didn't think I'd get an answer.
Bill R-4581