"I do however pose this question.
If I were to show you a Silver Strike/Token would you first question me where or how I obtained it before you determined what it was."

Bob; If you showed me a silver strike, I think that you and I could agree that there would be no discussion about where or how you obtained it. We would already know what it was.

However, this make believe commemorative tournament participant's token being passed off as a silver strike will have it's own baggage down the road when everyone familiar with it will know of it's tainted "pedigree" and where it came from.