John; At the chapter meeting at which I was present, Robert Eisenstadt did not convey any request from the National. He explicitly requested the roster so that HE could study it to determine who were CC & GTCC members and who were not. After reading the emails that Robert posted, his beef should be with National for not giving him the information that Dick Brach says he forwarded to CC & GTCC as far as the percentage of non-club members who belonged to the Chaper are concerned.... not information on individuals. We're not talking FBI or CIA matters here.

I'm still of the opinon that Robert was not entitled to the complete Chapter roster from Chapter President Brach. I fail to understand how Robert (or anyone else) could determine who was a CC & GTCC member and who was not, even if he was provided the roster, if the Chapter couldn't even make that determination. You, or I, or Peter, are not entitled to know which CC & GTCC members have requested that their membership status and/or addresses be kept confidential. Did Robert have a complete roster of CC & GTCC members to compare to the Chapter roster? If so, he was not entitled to that either in my opinion.... nor is any other non-officer or non-appointed official of CC & GTCC.

So whom are YOU voting for John?