OK I'm putting my head into the fire on this one.

Slab or don't slab. I'm my own guide. No slabbed chips will enter my collection.

Grading system or things as they are. I'm sticking to the simple methods which work just fine. If someone wants to start a system, or jump off a bridge, "good luck".

I am against a club policy, rule or whatever that bans these efforts. I don't think either will fly anyway. Boycott, ##### on them, burn them, I don't care. But the club should not have an official rule or policy which restricts the freedom of the members to make a personal choice.

I also don't think the hobby is so fragile that slabbing or grading will do any harm. Don't forget that every one of us has the personal choice to accept or reject either of these as we PERSONALLY choose.

I'm against both...

"War? What is it good for" Edwin Starr ;-)