I'm green. I'm new here. I haven't read anyone else's response as I'm out the door to work.
Let's table this proposal for at least six months. This idea of an official club rating system only seems to come as a response to the Campiglia-Wells system. The only place I've run across any use of C-W is here on this BB and it's only used as a source of Hoo-Rah. If there is a want for a grading system we could probably gauge better at a slightly later date.
This is an important and timely topic and I support this forum for discussion.