The Chip Board
Custom Search
   


The Chip Board Archive 02

The definition of extortion ...

... is worded differently in California, but the essential provisions are the same. Case law is clear, however, that a threat to file a lawsuit can NEVER constitute extortion. The reason is a matter of public policy; that is, the filing of a frivolous lawsuit has other possible remedies or sanctions (e.g., financial penalties, an award of attorney's fees or the filing of a countersuit for vexatious litigation or malicious prosecution) AND a determination of whether or not a lawsuit is frivolous cannot be made until after it is filed.

Furthermore, the "threat" of filing a lawsuit, even if frivolous, does not threaten an UNLAWFUL act -- and to use the Colorado language, it would not be "invoking action by any third party", as it "threatens" only action by the speaker.

I am not familiar with Colorado case law, but suspect based on the language that the end result would be the same as in California.

MAYBE if someone said straight out, "Even though I know it would be completely without merit [which is the legal standard for "frivolous" litigation], I will sue you anyway" it MIGHT constitute extortion if combined with an attempt to induce one of the proscribed results. I've never seen a published case where that occurred. ----- jim o\-S

Messages In This Thread

This is Why chip collecting Starts to SUCK
Opps Forgot
Renee - You are a TOTAL LOSER
Re: Renee - You are a TOTAL LOSER
Re: Renee - You are a TOTAL LOSER
Re: Renee -Like Talking To A Brick
I think bricks have more brains.
Re: I think bricks have more brains.
Re: Renee - You are a TOTAL LOSER
Re: Renee - You are a TOTAL LOSER
Re: I agree with Bob & Dick EOM
ALL of these kinds of disputes should be ...
I see nothing wrong, legally ...
Re: I'm having the same posting problem. (EOM)
Re: I see nothing wrong, legally ...
Re: Bob, you tease!
Re: Bob, you tease!
If you really want to tease him ...
Re: If you really want to tease him ...
Lifted from the cover of this month's ...
Re: Lifted from the cover of this month's ...
I'm prepared to pay handsomely ...
Re: Bob & Jim
Re: Bob & Jim
Re: Bob & Jim
In context of their conversation ...
Re: In context of their conversation ...
Clear, Bright Line for this one ...
Re: Clear, Bright Line for this one ...
The definition of extortion ...
Re: The definition of extortion ...
Clear, Bright Line for this one ...
How did this happen, Greg? ...
Show me your ignorance
Re: Show me your ignorance
Re: Show me your ignorance
Re: Show me your ignorance
Re: Show me your ignorance
Glad I collect Stamps
Re: Glad I collect Stamps
Re: Glad I collect Stamps
Re: Glad I collect Stamps
Re: 46S???
Re: 46S???
Re: 46S???

Copyright 2022 David Spragg